When Evidence Disappears in the Middle of an Investor Lawsuit
Key Takeaways: If a company deletes Slack or WhatsApp messages while your fraud case is pending, it may face serious consequences. The PSLRA pauses discovery during a motion to dismiss, but parties with actual notice of the allegations must still preserve relevant evidence, and courts can sanction willful failures to do so. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37(e), courts can order measures to cure prejudice when electronic evidence is lost, and they can impose adverse inferences, dismissal, or default judgment only if a party intended to deprive the other side of it. Broker-dealers have separate recordkeeping duties under SEC Rule 17a-4 and FINRA Rule 4511, and Pennsylvania criminal statutes such as 18 Pa.C.S. § 4910 may apply when evidence is destroyed on purpose. Investors may be able to seek targeted discovery or preservation relief during the stay, but they generally need concrete facts showing a real risk that evidence will be lost.
If a company appears to be deleting Slack or WhatsApp messages while your fraud case is pending, that conduct may expose it to serious consequences. Federal law generally requires parties in private securities litigation to preserve relevant electronic evidence, even while discovery is paused. For investors in Newtown Square and across Pennsylvania, the most important step is often to raise preservation concerns early, before more data is lost.
If you suspect that messages tied to your investment losses are being destroyed, Kaskela Law can review your situation. Call 484-229-0750 or contact us now to discuss your options.

Why Workplace Chat Apps Matter in Securities Fraud Cases
Messaging platforms have become the place where many corporate decisions actually get made. Executives who choose their words carefully in earnings calls and SEC filings may speak much more candidly on Slack or WhatsApp. In a securities fraud case, those informal conversations can be some of the strongest evidence of scienter, which is the defendant’s intent to deceive, or its knowledge or reckless disregard that its public statements were false or misleading.
Ephemeral messaging tools can make this problem worse. Some apps let messages disappear automatically. If a company leaves those settings in place after its duty to preserve arises, critical evidence may vanish without anyone pressing delete. Courts have treated a failure to turn off auto-delete features as a failure to take reasonable steps to preserve evidence, although the outcome depends heavily on the facts.
What These Messages Can Reveal
Internal chats can fill gaps that formal documents leave open. Investors’ counsel often look for evidence such as:
- Executives discussing problems that were not disclosed to the market
- Sales or accounting teams flagging irregularities before a stock drop
- Insiders coordinating trades around nonpublic information
- Discussions about how to phrase public statements to avoid alarming investors
How the PSLRA Discovery Stay Affects Your Case
Under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act, discovery is generally paused while a motion to dismiss is pending. Under 15 U.S.C. § 78u-4(b)(3)(B), courts stay all discovery during any pending motion to dismiss, unless the court finds that particularized discovery is necessary to preserve evidence or to prevent undue prejudice to a party. As a result, investors usually cannot demand internal documents early in the case.
The stay does not give defendants permission to destroy evidence. Under 15 U.S.C. § 78u-4(b)(3)(C)(i), during the stay any party with actual notice of the allegations must treat relevant documents, data compilations (including electronically stored data), and tangible objects in its custody or control as if they were subject to a continuing request for production. Under § 78u-4(b)(3)(C)(ii), a court may sanction a party aggrieved by another party’s willful failure to preserve that evidence. Electronic messages generally fall within this duty.
Seeking Relief During the Stay
Investors are not always powerless while the stay is in place. The statute’s exception for particularized discovery to preserve evidence may give plaintiffs a way to ask the court for targeted relief. Some courts have entered preservation orders covering specific messaging platforms, though courts disagree on whether such orders are needed given the automatic preservation duty. Courts generally read the exception narrowly, so a request typically needs concrete facts showing a real risk that evidence will be lost.
💡 Pro Tip: Save any screenshots, emails, or forwarded messages you already have that show a company used Slack, WhatsApp, or similar tools for business. That information may help your attorney show a court which platforms need to be preserved.
Federal Spoliation Rules and Possible Sanctions
Spoliation means destroying or failing to preserve evidence that a party had a duty to keep. In federal court, which includes the Eastern District of Pennsylvania serving Newtown Square, Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37(e) governs lost electronically stored information. The rule applies when ESI that should have been preserved is lost because a party failed to take reasonable steps, and the information cannot be restored or replaced through additional discovery.
The duty to preserve typically begins when litigation is reasonably anticipated. That trigger point is often disputed in fraud cases. A company may argue it had no reason to expect a lawsuit. Investors may point to internal warnings, regulatory inquiries, or demand letters as evidence that a litigation hold should have issued much earlier.
Levels of Sanctions Depend on Intent
Courts generally scale sanctions to how culpable the destroying party was. Under Rule 37(e)(1), if the loss prejudices another party, a court may order measures no greater than necessary to cure that prejudice. Under Rule 37(e)(2), harsher remedies require a finding that the party acted with intent to deprive the other side of the information’s use in the litigation; negligence or even gross negligence is not enough.
| Sanction | General Standard Under Rule 37(e) |
|---|---|
| Curative measures (for example, additional discovery or allowing evidence about the loss) | Prejudice to the opposing party |
| Adverse inference that lost information was unfavorable | Intent to deprive |
| Dismissal of claims or default judgment | Intent to deprive |
An adverse inference instruction can be powerful in an investor lawsuit. It may allow or require a jury to presume that deleted messages were unfavorable to the party that lost them. However, courts do not impose this sanction lightly, and proving intent often requires substantial circumstantial evidence.
Regulatory Recordkeeping Duties for Securities Firms
Some securities firms face independent legal duties to keep business communications. SEC Rule 17a-4 (17 C.F.R. § 240.17a-4) requires broker-dealers to preserve business-related communications, including electronic messages, for set retention periods, generally three years for communications, with some other records kept for six years. Those duties extend to Slack, WhatsApp, and other platforms when employees use them for business, and the SEC has imposed substantial penalties on firms for unpreserved off-channel communications.
Firms subject to these rules may also face storage-format requirements. Electronic records have traditionally had to be kept in a non-rewriteable, non-erasable format, often called WORM storage; 2022 amendments also permit an alternative audit-trail system. FINRA Rule 4511 also requires member firms to preserve books and records consistent with FINRA rules and SEC Rule 17a-4. Deliberately deleting covered messages may therefore be a regulatory violation separate from any litigation sanction. These rules apply to regulated entities such as broker-dealers, not every public company.
Pennsylvania Criminal Laws That May Apply
Pennsylvania law also treats some forms of evidence destruction as crimes. Prosecutors, not private investors, decide whether to bring criminal charges. Still, these statutes show how seriously Pennsylvania treats this conduct, and they may become relevant if a regulator or prosecutor gets involved.
Tampering With Evidence and Records
Several provisions of the Pennsylvania Crimes Code may apply to destroyed communications. Under 18 Pa.C.S. § 4910(1), a person commits a second-degree misdemeanor if, believing an official proceeding or investigation is pending or about to be instituted, he alters, destroys, conceals, or removes any record, document, or thing with intent to impair its verity or availability. Electronic chats may qualify as a "record, document or thing."
Other statutes can reach conduct even before any proceeding begins. Under 18 Pa.C.S. § 4104(a), falsifying, destroying, removing, or concealing a writing or record, knowing one has no privilege to do so, with intent to deceive or injure anyone or to conceal any wrongdoing, is a first-degree misdemeanor. Under 18 Pa.C.S. § 4911(a)(3) and (b), intentionally and unlawfully destroying or concealing records required by law to be kept is generally a second-degree misdemeanor, and becomes a third-degree felony when the intent is to defraud or injure anyone. Courts also retain contempt powers to punish violations of their orders, including preservation orders.
Deadlines Investors Should Not Overlook
Waiting too long can cost you both your claim and your evidence. Under 42 Pa.C.S. § 5524(7), Pennsylvania tort claims sounding in deceit or fraud generally must be filed within two years, unless another limitation period applies. You can review this provision in Pennsylvania’s Judicial Code limitation periods. Federal Section 10(b) claims follow separate deadlines: generally two years after discovery of the facts constituting the violation, and no more than five years after the violation, an outer limit that cannot be tolled.
State law offers other remedies with their own timelines. Under 15 Pa.C.S. § 2576(a) and (c), a shareholder of a registered Pennsylvania corporation may sue on the corporation’s behalf to recover certain profits from a controlling person or group if the corporation fails to act within 60 days after a written request. Those actions generally must be filed within two years after the profit was realized. To learn how state claims fit together, read our overview of securities fraud in Pennsylvania.
💡 Pro Tip: Filing promptly can do more than protect your deadline. A formal claim can put defendants on clear notice, which may strengthen later arguments that their preservation duty had already begun.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Can a company delete messages while the PSLRA discovery stay is in effect?
Generally, no. Under 15 U.S.C. § 78u-4(b)(3)(C), parties with actual notice of the allegations must preserve relevant evidence during the stay, and courts may sanction willful failures to do so. Rule 37(e) and the common law may impose preservation duties even earlier, once litigation is reasonably anticipated.
2. Do Slack and WhatsApp messages count as evidence?
In many cases, yes. Courts generally treat business messages on these platforms as electronically stored information, and their loss can be addressed under Rule 37(e).
3. What is a litigation hold?
A litigation hold is an instruction that generally requires a company to suspend normal deletion practices and preserve potentially relevant information, which may include turning off auto-delete settings on messaging apps.
4. Will the court automatically punish a company that deleted messages?
No. Sanctions depend on the facts, including when the duty to preserve began, whether reasonable steps were taken, whether the information can be restored, whether investors were prejudiced, and whether there was intent to deprive.
5. Can I report the deletion to prosecutors?
You may report suspected misconduct, but prosecutors decide independently whether to pursue charges under statutes such as 18 Pa.C.S. § 4910. Criminal proceedings are separate from your civil claim.
Protecting Your Recovery When Evidence Is at Risk
Deleted Slack and WhatsApp messages can undermine an investor’s ability to prove fraud, but the law may provide tools to respond. The PSLRA generally requires preservation even during the discovery stay, Rule 37(e) allows courts to impose sanctions in appropriate circumstances, regulatory rules may bind securities firms, and Pennsylvania criminal statutes may reach intentional destruction. Acting quickly may help preserve both your claims and the evidence that supports them.
If you are concerned about disappearing evidence in your investment loss case, speak with a PSLRA discovery stay lawyer at Kaskela Law. Call 484-229-0750 or schedule your consultation today.
Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Every case is unique, and results may vary. Consult an attorney about your specific circumstances.

